Skip to main content

Mark Zuckerberg is trying to do what Google did with Android — but he learned all the wrong lessons

Apple CEO Tim Cook (left), and Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg (right)
Tim Cook, Mark Zuckerberg.
  • Meta's effort to build the metaverse is a way to wrangle back control of consumer data from Apple, experts say.
  • The attempt to gain a competitive advantage over Apple is reminiscent of Google's effort to build Android. 
  • Google's effort paid off, but it's likely that Mark Zuckerberg learned the wrong lessons from recent history.  

Meta wants to wrangle control away from Apple.

The company's multi-billion dollar effort to build the metaverse and its decision last year to rebrand from Facebook to Meta is a way to reclaim control of consumer data from Apple's clutches, experts say. 

It's similar to why Google developed Android, but Mark Zuckerberg's project seems to miss one key ingredient that made Android a success. 

Apple's change messed with Facebook's business model

Last year, Apple changed its privacy policy, making it harder for Facebook to track and monetize its advertising. 

"Apple has essentially made Facebook's returns revert to the mean because they removed a massive data source in terms of their access to app user data," said Mark Zgutowicz, a Meta analyst at Benchmark. 

The change could come at a company-threatening cost to Meta.

Over 95% of the company's revenue comes from mobile devices, according to Needham tech analyst Laura Martin. Meta's COO told investors that Apple's new policy would result in $10 billion of lower revenue in 2022. 

"Meta's goal is to replace Apple's smartphone centrality in consumers' lives," Martin recently wrote in a note to investors. 

Android vs. Metaverse

Google reportedly created Android more than a decade ago for the same reason: to compete with Apple. 

In 2007, Google scrapped its planned first-iteration Android phone just before launch and redesigned it to look like the sleeker first-generation iPhone, according to the book Dogfight, by journalist and author Fred Vogelstein.

Steve Jobs, Apple's co-founder, was reportedly incensed by Google's introduction of Android, which he believed to be an illegal copy of the iPhone, reportedly calling it a "stolen product," according to Walter Isaacson's 2011 book, Steve Jobs.

However, there's one main difference between Google's attempt to escape Apple's supremacy and Meta's gambit: there was already proof of consumer demand for the product Google was allegedly duping. Apple had sold 1 million of its first-generation iPhones just 74 days after its introduction.

Google's pivot paid off. Will Meta's? 

Google saw where Apple was going and continued to develop its Android platform to match Apple's iOS. The company has also continued to invest in making its smartphones, a device it knows people want.

Google's bet paid off. Android is now the dominant mobile operating system worldwide. 

But Google was a fast follower; Meta's pivot could be more dangerous because it's investing in a largely untested product: the metaverse. 

"It's a massively huge risk, and I think the primary risk is there are no tangibles right now," Zgutowicz said. 

Some analysts on Wall Street are skeptical Meta will pull this off. 

"Even if the Metaverse does turn out to be the immersive hardware-based vision that Meta articulates, will Meta really be the winning hardware provider to consumers?" Martin asked in a recent note. 

While sticking to the old business model under Apple's new privacy regime would've likely cost Facebook billions in lost advertising revenue, building an entire virtual world from scratch doesn't exactly come cheap. 

Meta has reported more than $19 billion in losses from its metaverse business unit since the start of last year, turning off many investors, including one who wrote an open letter to Zuckerberg urging him to stem the losses. Meta's stock is down more than 70% so far this year. 

Read the original article on Business Insider


from Business Insider https://ift.tt/StpL74v
via IFTTT

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Nintendo Switch has been the US’s bestselling console for 23 straight months

Photo by James Bareham / The Verge It’s been a good two years for the Nintendo Switch. According to Nintendo, the gaming tablet has been the bestselling console in the US for 23 straight months. And according to data from the NPD Group, it just had its best October ever, moving 735,926 units of both the Switch and Switch Lite in the US. The company says that represents a 136 percent increase compared to last year. To date, the Switch has sold 22.5 million units in the US, and last week Nintendo revealed that more than 68 million units have been sold globally . “We’re excited about our momentum,” says Nick Chavez, Nintendo of America’s SVP of sales and marketing. Chavez puts the company’s big October down to two main factors. One is a better supply of stock; this year in particular, it’s often been hard to find a Switch on store shelves. This has only been exacerbated by increased demand due to a combination of the pandemic and the breakout success of Animal Crossing: New Horizons . ...

Instagram accidentally reinstated Pornhub’s banned account

After years of on-and-off temporary suspensions, Instagram permanently banned Pornhub’s account in September. Then, for a short period of time this weekend, the account was reinstated. By Tuesday, it was permanently banned again. “This was done in error,” an Instagram spokesperson told TechCrunch. “As we’ve said previously, we permanently disabled this Instagram account for repeatedly violating our policies.” Instagram’s content guidelines prohibit  nudity and sexual solicitation . A Pornhub spokesperson told TechCrunch, though, that they believe the adult streaming platform’s account did not violate any guidelines. Instagram has not commented on the exact reasoning for the ban, or which policies the account violated. It’s worrying from a moderation perspective if a permanently banned Instagram account can accidentally get switched back on. Pornhub told TechCrunch that its account even received a notice from Instagram, stating that its ban had been a mistake (that message itse...

Marvel teases Zodiac spy thriller. Heres what fans are theorizing.

Marvel's whiplash New York Comic Con announcements have brought fans disappointing cancellation news, sneak previews, and, of course, more secrecy. Taking to the stage Oct. 8, Marvel execs announced the end of Daredevil: Born Again , which will conclude with its third season next year. The team also gave attendees a taste of the upcoming third season of X-Men '97 and VisionQuest , the last installment of the Scarlet Witch's television saga. But the online buzz is all about its mysterious new show, Zodiac , set to debut in 2028. SEE ALSO: What's new to streaming this week? (Oct. 9, 2026) Flashing the new logo on the big screen, Marvel Television head Brad Winderbaum wouldn't say much about the show's plot or characters — perhaps some meta marketing for what is being dubbed a Marvel universe spy drama — but he did hint there was more than meets the eye. "If you're a fan of the comics, there is a ...